Effective Strategies for Reducing Clothing Return Rate in E-Commerce

E-commerce businesses, particularly apparel retailers in the fashion industry, face significant challenges with high return rates due to sizing issues and customer expectations. Returns can cost retailers up to 65% of their profits, highlighting the importance of reducing them. Effective strategies to minimize returns not only save money but also improve customer satisfaction and loyalty. The text will outline actionable strategies to address the root causes of returns and enhance the shopping experience.

Introduction: The Growing Challenge of High Return Rates in E-Commerce

In the world of e-commerce, returns are a major headache for retailers, particularly in the fashion industry. Often, customers purchase items with the intent to return them, especially when buying clothing in various sizes or styles to try on at home. The issue is not only financial but also environmental, as high return rates significantly impact profitability and sustainability goals. Returns can be costly, with the online apparel sector seeing a return rate as high as 24.4%, translating to billions of dollars lost each year. These returns are driven by a variety of factors, ranging from poor fit to misleading product descriptions. As online shopping becomes the norm, it’s more important than ever for fashion brands to find effective strategies to reduce these return rates and create a better shopping experience for their customers. By addressing the root causes of returns, brands can save money, improve customer satisfaction, and minimize their environmental impact.

Understanding the Impact of Returns on E-Commerce

The financial and environmental impact of returns in e-commerce is far-reaching. According to recent data, return rates in e-commerce can be up to three times higher than those in brick-and-mortar stores. For the apparel industry, the average return rate is 24.4%, equating to a staggering $38 billion in returned merchandise annually. These returns lead to direct costs, such as shipping fees, restocking, and the potential for unsellable items. In addition to these financial losses, returns also contribute to environmental strain, generating excess packaging waste and increasing carbon emissions from the logistics of shipping returned items. As a result, the issue of returns isn’t just a matter of lost sales—it’s a multifaceted challenge that can impact profitability, customer loyalty, and sustainability efforts. Retailers must adopt strategies to manage returns effectively if they want to remain competitive and environmentally responsible.

E-commerce return rates can be 2x to 3x higher than brick and mortar stores

E-commerce return rates are significantly higher than those of brick-and-mortar stores. According to a study by the National Retail Federation, the average return rate for online purchases is around 20-30%, which is 2-3 times higher than the return rate for in-store purchases. This disparity can be attributed to the fact that online shoppers are more likely to purchase items without trying them on or seeing them in person, leading to a higher likelihood of returns. Unlike in-store shoppers who can physically inspect and try on items before making a purchase, online shoppers often rely on product descriptions and images, which can sometimes be misleading or insufficient. This uncertainty drives the higher return rates in e-commerce, making it crucial for retailers to implement strategies that can bridge this gap and reduce returns.

A 24.4% online apparel return rate means $38 billion returns

The online apparel return rate is a significant concern for retailers, with a staggering 24.4% of online apparel orders being returned. This translates to a whopping $38 billion in returns, which can have a substantial impact on a retailer’s bottom line. The high return rate can be attributed to various factors, including incorrect sizing, poor product descriptions, and the lack of virtual try-on tools. Virtual try-on technology, for instance, can help customers visualize how an item will fit and look on their body, reducing the uncertainty that often leads to returns. By addressing these issues, retailers can not only reduce return rates but also enhance customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Common Reasons for Clothing Returns

The primary drivers of high return rates in the fashion industry can be broadly categorized into three main issues: fit, misrepresentation of products, and customer behavior patterns such as bracketing.

  • Bracketing: Many online shoppers practice bracketing, a tactic where they purchase multiple items with the intent of returning those that don’t meet their expectations. This practice is especially common in the apparel industry, where customers are unsure of how clothing will fit them and often order multiple sizes or colors of the same item to compare, complicating return management for retailers.
  • Fit Issues: Poor fit is one of the most common reasons for returns, as 70% of fashion-related returns stem from items not fitting properly. Sizing inconsistencies across different brands and inaccurate size charts exacerbate this problem, leading to customer dissatisfaction and returns.
  • Product Misrepresentation: When a product’s appearance or features don’t match what is presented online, it can lead to disappointment and returns. This includes issues such as color discrepancies, fabric textures, or the fit not living up to what was expected based on online images or descriptions.

Understanding these root causes is the first step in crafting strategies to reduce returns. By addressing fit issues, offering more accurate product descriptions, and managing customer expectations, retailers can reduce the likelihood of returns and create a better shopping experience.

They purchased with the intent to return

Bracketing, or purchasing multiple items with the intent to return some of them, is a common practice among online shoppers. According to a study, 41% of consumers have purchased multiple items with the intent to return some of them. This behavior is particularly prevalent in the fashion industry, where customers often order multiple sizes or colors to try on at home and then return the ones that don’t meet their expectations. While this practice can increase sales in the short term, it also leads to higher return rates and associated costs. Retailers need to find a balance between accommodating this behavior and implementing measures to reduce its impact, such as offering detailed sizing guides and virtual try-on tools to help customers make more informed decisions.

The product didn’t match your description

Inaccurate product descriptions can lead to returns, as customers may purchase items that do not match their expectations. According to a study, customers rely heavily on product descriptions and photos when making online purchases, and any discrepancies can result in dissatisfaction and returns. For instance, if the color, fabric, or fit of an item differs from what was described or shown online, customers are likely to return the product. To mitigate this, retailers should ensure that product descriptions are detailed and accurate, and that photos are high-quality and true to the actual product. By providing clear and honest information, retailers can set realistic customer expectations and reduce the likelihood of returns.

Streamline Returns with WeSupply’s Analytics

Understanding the primary reasons for clothing returns—fit issues, product misrepresentation, and customer behaviors like bracketing—retailers can transform these challenges into opportunities with WeSupply’s Return Analytics. This powerful tool provides actionable insights, helping businesses address the root causes of returns and improve the customer experience.

Key Features of WeSupply’s Return Analytics:

  • Identify Return Trends: Pinpoint patterns in sizing discrepancies or product descriptions that lead to dissatisfaction.

  • Optimize Operations: Use detailed data to refine product offerings, enhance customer satisfaction, and streamline return processes.

  • Reduce Return Rates: Implement informed changes that directly address common return drivers, lowering overall return rates.

  • Improve Customer Loyalty: Create a more seamless and positive post-purchase experience, building trust and repeat business.

With these features, WeSupply enables retailers to not only minimize return-related costs but also elevate the customer journey for long-term success.

Improving Customer Satisfaction through Accurate Product Information

Accurate product information on product pages is essential in setting customer expectations and reducing returns. One of the most common reasons for returns is the mismatch between what customers expect from a product and what they receive. Retailers can mitigate this by offering clear and detailed product descriptions, high-quality images, and easy-to-read sizing charts.

  • Sizing and Fit Accuracy: Providing detailed and helpful sizing guides is critical. These should include measurements such as length, width, height, and weight, as well as tips on how the item fits relative to other sizes. Featuring customer reviews with fit feedback can also help shoppers make more informed decisions.
  • Detailed Product Descriptions: Product descriptions should highlight the key features, benefits, and material details of an item. Transparency in how the product fits, feels, and functions will help customers make purchasing decisions based on realistic expectations.
  • High-Quality Product Images: Product images are a visual representation of what customers can expect. Offering a variety of images showing the product from different angles, as well as on models of different body types, helps customers visualize the fit and style. The clearer the visual representation, the less likely a customer is to feel misled and, therefore, less likely to return the item.

Boost Customer Satisfaction with Accurate Product Insights

Accurate product information is essential for improving customer satisfaction and reducing return rates. WeSupply’s SKU-level Returns Analytics provides valuable insights to help businesses refine their product offerings and align with customer expectations. By identifying specific return reasons like color, quality, and size issues, retailers can make informed adjustments to enhance the shopping experience.

Key Features of WeSupply’s SKU-Level Returns Analytics:

  • Optimize Sizing Charts: Adjust sizing charts to better reflect customer feedback and reduce fit-related returns.

  • Encourage Reviews: Identify products needing more reviews to boost transparency and buyer confidence.

  • Leverage Feedback: Collect and use customer insights to address product fit concerns effectively.

With these tools, WeSupply empowers businesses to create a more accurate and satisfying shopping experience for their customers.

Enhancing the Online Shopping Experience to Reduce Returns

A seamless and intuitive online shopping experience is essential in reducing return rates. By simplifying the shopping journey and providing customers with clear, accessible information, brands can reduce customer friction and prevent returns.

  • Simplifying the Checkout Process: A complicated or lengthy checkout process can deter customers and lead to confusion about shipping fees, delivery times, or the return policy. Brands should ensure that the checkout is simple, quick, and transparent, with clear options for shipping and returns.

  • Incentivizing Purchases: Offering incentives such as free returns, exchange shipping, or discounts for keeping products can help reduce the likelihood of returns. Customers who feel that returning an item is easy and hassle-free are more likely to stick with the brand for future purchases.

  • Customer Education: Educating customers on how to use and care for products can prevent returns due to misunderstandings. Brands can offer how-to guides, video tutorials, and detailed instructions to assist customers in setting up and using products, helping them get the most out of their purchase.

Simplify Returns for Your Customers and Support Team

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you: simplify the Return experience with just a few clicks, reduce customer service calls and manual processing, notify your customer about their refund, automate returns and reduce user error.

WeSupply: Seamless Post-Purchase Solutions to Cut Returns

By extending the enhancement of the online shopping experience into the post-purchase phase, businesses can proactively reduce returns and build lasting customer trust. WeSupply’s tools empower retailers to keep customers informed, set clear expectations, and deliver a fully branded post-purchase journey that reinforces satisfaction and loyalty.

Key Features of WeSupply for Reducing Returns:

  • Estimated Delivery Date: Embed accurate delivery timelines into your logistics to set clear customer expectations and gain trust.

  • Order Tracking: Provide real-time tracking updates and shipment information to address customer concerns and boost loyalty.

  • Delivery Notifications: Proactively inform customers about order status, delays, or changes to avoid frustration and unnecessary inquiries.

  • Branded Tracking Pages: Create a cohesive, branded experience where customers can check order status directly, eliminating reliance on third-party tracking sites.

With WeSupply, businesses can turn the post-purchase phase into a powerful opportunity to enhance satisfaction, reduce returns, and build long-term relationships.


Managing Returns and Feedback Effectively

A clear and consistent return policy is vital in managing returns effectively. Customers appreciate knowing exactly what to expect when they decide to return an item. Retailers should create transparent policies that are easy to find and understand.

  • Clear Return Policy: Ensure that return policies are easy to understand and clearly outlined on the website. Highlight exclusions, time limits, and conditions under which returns are accepted. Providing a self-service portal can help customers with return-related inquiries and streamline the return process. A straightforward, hassle-free return process improves customer trust and reduces the likelihood of return-related dissatisfaction.
  • Feedback Collection: Gathering feedback from customers who return items helps identify recurring problems. Whether it’s due to sizing, style, or quality issues, understanding why customers are returning products allows retailers to adjust their offerings and improve future customer experiences.

Streamline Returns and Boost Satisfaction with WeSupply

WeSupply simplifies managing returns and feedback, creating a seamless, customer-friendly process that reduces friction and boosts satisfaction. From encouraging exchanges to offering personalized notifications, WeSupply ensures an efficient and branded experience that keeps customers coming back.

Key Features of WeSupply for Managing Returns and Feedback:

  • Branded Returns Portal: Deliver a consistent, omnichannel experience without relying on generic third-party pages.

  • Self-Service Returns: Empower customers with control over their returns, saving time and reducing support queries.

  • Returns Tracking: Provide real-time updates so customers can easily monitor the status of their returns.

  • Logistics Analytics: Track Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) and Net Promoter Score (NPS) to fine-tune your processes.

  • Seamless Integrations: Connect with hundreds of third-party tools for a unified and cost-effective solution.

With these features, WeSupply helps businesses streamline returns, enhance customer satisfaction, and make data-driven decisions to improve the post-purchase experience.

Book a demo today to see how WeSupply can transform your returns process!


Environmental and Financial Implications of Returns

The environmental impact of returns is a significant concern for apparel retailers. E-commerce returns contribute to packaging waste and increased carbon emissions from transportation. The financial strain of returns is also significant, with businesses incurring costs for shipping, restocking, and handling unsellable returned merchandise.

  • Sustainability and Cost Savings: Reducing returns can have a profound impact on a company’s sustainability efforts and bottom line. By addressing fit issues, improving product descriptions, and managing customer expectations, businesses can reduce waste, lower carbon emissions, and retain more revenue.

  • Optimizing Inventory Management: Efficient returns management allows companies to restock returned items quickly, reducing the financial strain of having unsellable stock. Additionally, brands that successfully manage their return rates are better able to forecast demand, which can lead to more accurate inventory planning and reduced overstocking.


Optimize Returns for Environmental and Financial Savings with WeSupply

WeSupply helps mitigate the environmental and financial impact of returns by offering solutions that streamline the process and reduce waste. With Green Returns, customers can keep low-cost items, avoiding unnecessary shipping and reducing landfill contributions. This not only lowers the cost of return labels but also enhances customer satisfaction by quickly processing refunds or exchanges without requiring returns of items that would otherwise go unused.

Key Features for Environmental and Financial Impact:

Start optimizing your return process and discover the savings with our ROI Calculator.


Customer Retention Post-Return: Maintaining Brand Loyalty

Even after a return, maintaining customer engagement is crucial for preserving long-term brand loyalty. To minimize the negative impact of returns, retailers can offer alternatives like store credit or exchanges, which not only provide customers with an opportunity to find a product that better suits their needs but also keep the revenue within the business. Additionally, personalized recommendations based on previous purchases can help guide customers toward items they are more likely to love, enhancing their shopping experience and making it more likely they will return in the future. When customers see that their satisfaction is prioritized through flexible return policies and thoughtful post-return interactions, they are more likely to remain loyal to the brand, reducing the risk of churn and turning a potentially negative experience into an opportunity for continued relationship-building.


Boost Customer Retention with Nosto & Justuno Integrations

WeSupply helps foster customer retention post-return by offering personalized experiences that keep customers engaged and loyal to your brand. Through integrations with Nosto and Justuno, WeSupply allows businesses to deliver tailored product recommendations and promotions at key moments, ensuring a seamless post-purchase experience that drives repeat business.

Key Features for Customer Retention:

  • Justuno x WeSupply Integration: Leverage pop-ups and banners on tracking pages to showcase relevant offers, upsell products, and increase sales opportunities with targeted promotions.

Combat inconvenience with proactivity & self service

Book a quick call with our experts to see how WeSupply can help you make returns easy for your customers with a beautiful, self-service solution that makes their experience easier while also providing new ways to lower costs and earn back revenue.

Conclusion: Moving Toward a Return-Free Future

In conclusion, reducing return rates requires a multifaceted approach that reduces returns and addresses the underlying causes of dissatisfaction. By focusing on accurate sizing, improving the overall customer experience, leveraging technology like 3D fitting rooms and data analytics, and ensuring clear communication regarding product expectations and return policies, retailers can significantly reduce returns. However, it’s important to understand that these strategies should work together in a holistic way. This approach not only reduces the frequency of returns but also fosters customer loyalty and trust. By prioritizing the customer experience, offering personalized post-return solutions, and constantly refining the shopping journey, brands can work towards a future where returns are minimized, and customers feel valued and connected with the brand for the long term.

Back to blog